Cookie Gallery

A homemade classic with a cozy kick, our Chocolate Chip cookie has all the gooey, rich goodness you love, but with a twist. Sugar's Shoppe adds a hint of cinnamon and spice for a subtle Mexican hot chocolate vibe, making this familiar favorite feel warm, bold, and just a little magical. 

 A classic, chewy, and refreshing lemon cookie coated in powdered sugar. Our Lemon Crinkle cookie is sunshine in every bite. With bright citrus flavor and a soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture, it’s the perfect balance of sweet and tangy. A light, zesty treat that brings homemade comfort and a splash of joy to your day. 

Cozy, classic, and packed with cinnamon-sugar goodness, our Snickerdoodle cookies are the warm hug of the cookie world. Soft in the center with a delicate crackle on top, each bite is a nostalgic taste of home, handcrafted with love and just the right touch of spice. Perfect with a glass of milk or a quiet moment to yourself. 

 This one’s for the peanut butter lovers. Our soft, chewy chocolate chip cookie is stuffed with creamy peanut butter and topped with crunchy, colorful peanut butter chocolate candies. It’s rich, nostalgic, and indulgent, like your favorite childhood treat, all grown up and freshly baked. 

 Gluten-free never tasted so dreamy. Our Almond Croissant Cookie features a soft, buttery cookie base filled with rich almond frangipane, capturing the delicate, nutty sweetness of a fresh almond croissant... All in one indulgent bite. Lightly crisp on the outside, tender inside, and full of Parisian café charm. 

Available June - August

 Get campfire vibes without the smoke. Our ooey gooey S’mores Cookie starts with a rich chocolate chip base, stuffed with a soft homemade marshmallow and rolled in golden graham cracker crumbs. It’s toasty, melty, and nostalgic just like your favorite summer memory, baked into every bite. 

Available May - June

 Experience a vibrant twist on a classic treat with our Ube Cookie. Soft, chewy, and naturally purple, this cookie features the unique, subtly sweet flavor of ube, a beloved Filipino purple yam. Each bite offers a creamy, slightly nutty taste that’s both comforting and delightfully unexpected, bringing a beautiful splash of color and warmth to your cookie jar. 

Available November - December

 A delicious holiday classic, only here for the season. Our White Chocolate Cranberry Oatmeal Cookie combines chewy oats, sweet-tart dried cranberries, and creamy white chocolate chips for a festive flavor that feels like a warm hug. It’s the perfect seasonal treat to savor while it lasts! 

Available November - December

 A Sugar's Shoppe family favorite and a true taste of the season. Our Ginger Molasses Cookie is perfectly spiced, delightfully sweet, and melts in your mouth with every bite. With its soft texture and cozy flavor, it’s the ultimate holiday cookie. Warm, nostalgic, and only here for a limited time. 

Box of 6, individually wrapped cookies in a single flavor.

Box of 12, individually wrapped cookies in a single flavor.

Box of 36 individually wrapped cookies in a single flavor. 

Box of 6, individually wrapped cookies in flavors and quantities of your choosing.

Box of 12, individually wrapped cookies in flavors and quantities of your choosing.

12 individually wrapped cookies, customizable with the flavor(s) of your choosing.

Box of 36 cookies; perfect for parties and get togethers. 

Open to discussion of custom flavors - extra charge for flavors not listed on site.